Skip to content


Welsh Government more interested in fighting UK counterparts than helping people

The Constitutional and Legislative Affairs Committee has conducted an inquiry into the Welsh Government‘s handling of regulations regarding council tax reduction schemes. This followed the UK Government’s announcement that the benefit system, which gives households additional help to pay their council tax bills, would be devolved to local councils rather than run at a UK level. The Welsh Labour Government’s subsequent mishandling of this situation in Wales resulted in the recall of the Assembly during recess in order for people to be given this support.

The Committee’s report, which was published today, states that the “Welsh Government confused the political process with the legislative process. In doing so, we believe the Welsh Government may have, at the time, lost sight of the Assembly’s role as a legislative body”.

This whole fiasco could have been avoided if the Welsh Labour Government had acted properly. However it’s clear that the Welsh Labour Government was far more interested in a having a spat with the UK Government than it was in actually helping the people of Wales.

Rather than getting on with the job in hand, the then Local Government Minister chose to enter into a game of tit for tat and point scoring with Westminster.
“He continually blamed the UK Government for not producing figures he said he needed, but on closer examination we found that not only was this problem not encountered in Scotland and England, but the Minister himself admitted that what happens in England was of ‘little significance’ to him.

The Welsh Labour Government had a responsibility to ensure some of the poorest people in our society had appropriate support to help them with their Council Tax bills, yet instead its priority was merely to play politics.

The Minister handled this policy issue poorly, which is completely unacceptable given the considerable implications it had for people across Wales. The Welsh Labour Government needs to reassess how it deals with new and complex policy areas, because on this issue its performance was simply not good enough.

Posted in news.

Tagged with .


Wales needs its own NHS whistleblowing hotline

Wales needs its own a whistleblowing hotline to allow NHS staff to be able to anonymously report their concerns.

The Welsh Government Health Minister recently confirmed to me in a Written Question that there is currently “no whistleblowing hotline for NHS staff”.

Instead, staff are expected to contact a number, run by the Royal Mencap Society, that covers NHS and social care employees in both England and Wales.

The Welsh Liberal Democrats are calling on the Welsh Government to introduce a free hotline that is available solely for NHS staff in Wales.

It is absolutely critical that staff working within our NHS feel they are able to speak out and raise their concerns and that these concerns are taken seriously and acted upon.

The recent horrific scandals at Mid Staffordshire hospitals further highlighted the importance of NHS staff being able to blow the whistle on problems they have seen in their workplace. Routine neglect sadly became the norm at these hospitals due to a culture of fear, bullying and secrecy where staff were too scared to speak out. Such a scandal must never be allowed to happen again.

Whistleblowers are a valuable source of intelligence and should always be encouraged to come forward. If there are issues out there, then medical staff have a duty to disclose these concerns as it could save lives.

It is clear that for too long the Welsh Labour Government has sat back and thought it is fine for NHS organisations themselves to deal with whistleblowers. That just isn’t enough. People often don’t want to complain through their own organisation and would rather go straight to the top. Therefore the Welsh Government needs to strengthen the help offered to these brave people by offering a well-publicised hotline number. At the moment, the options available for those who want to voice genuine concerns and report problems are not coherent enough. The current number is not particularly well publicised and is unclear whether it is also for staff of NHS Wales. We need a Wales-wide point of contact.

Health is a devolved issue, therefore I see no reason why England and Wales should have the same whistleblowing initiatives. Wales needs its own hotline that is free to call and is available to all NHS staff.

Posted in news.

Tagged with .


Issuing fixed penalty notices to parents of children skipping school is counter-productive

Yesterday’s announcement by the Education Minister that fixed penalty notices will be issued to parents whose children are regularly absent from school will prove to be counter-productive.

The Minister’s decision has been based on the results of a consultation carried out between November 2012 and February 2013.

I believe this is a disproportionate response to a problem which requires a far more creative response than a fining system.

Evidence shows that children from poorer backgrounds are more likely to play truant and achieve poorer educational outcomes. I am concerned that fining parents of truant pupils will cause them even more economic hardship and will do nothing to address the problems of their child missing vital school hours.

It is also crucial that we consider the reasons why children are often absent from school.

There were just 53 responses to this consultation, including only 12 of the 22 Welsh local authorities, along with 16 schools/headteachers and 12 parents/carers. Of those 53, only just over half – 55% – agreed with the penalty notice option.

Fixed penalty fines can never replace targeted intervention and effective engagement with pupils and parents.

Whilst parents must take responsibility for their children’s behaviour and fulfil their obligation to ensure they attend school, a community-wide approach involving parents, police and local welfare officers would be much more effective than theses punitive measures being implemented by the Education Minister.

This is yet another attempt at a quick fix by the Minister which is unlikely to be of any benefit to the families concerned.

Posted in news.

Tagged with , .


Time to address the shortage of Welsh nurses

Every so often, Assembly Members have the opportunity to form their own law. We put forward an idea, it is entered into the ballot and then one of the ideas is drawn at random. The AM then has the opportunity to take that forward and it could eventually become law in Wales. Last month I was not lucky enough to be selected but my idea is something I feel strongly about so I will continue to campaign for it.

In the wake of the Mid Staffordshire scandal, I am calling for a change in the law to require minimum staffing levels for nurses in Wales.

The idea of setting minimum staffing quotas was put forward in the Francis Report, which looked at failings in the care provided by Mid Staffordshire NHS Trust and cited long-term low staffing levels as one reason which contributed to poor treatment.

While the Francis report predominately dealt with the NHS in England, figures from the Royal College of Nurses have revealed that Wales lags behind the rest of the UK in key indicators of nurse staffing levels. In Scottish wards there are 8.8 patients per patient, England 8.5, Northern Ireland 7.2 but in Wales each nurse will have to care for 10.5 patients. We also have the fewest nurses as a percentage of all hospital staff.

It is staggering to see the vast difference in the ratio of nurses to patients in Wales when compared to the rest of the UK. Once again Welsh Labour’s poverty of ambition has led to our NHS having to do more, but with less.

Nurses in Wales are working incredibly hard and are doing a great job, but there simply are not enough of them on Welsh wards to cope with the ever increasing number of patients. Earlier this year I visited an A&E department with a family member. Whilst I was there I met a nurse who was due to finish her shift 5 hours before she saw us. She could not go home because it would have left the ward with a dangerously low number of members of staff on duty. She was doing a very good job but was understandably tired. If she had made a mistake, would that have been her fault? Nurses make life and death decisions every day, they need to be as alert as possible.

Legislation requiring a minimum number of nurses per patient has been introduced in California, New South Wales and Victoria (Australia) where it has improved nurse staffing levels and patient care. Studies in California have shown that such a change has significantly reduced mortality rates.

Nurses who have fewer patients to tend to are able to spend a greater amount of their time with each patient and, as a result, can provide better care. Better care would mean we can get people out of hospital quicker and end the so called ‘bed-blocking’ we have heard a lot about recently, clearing space for other needy patients.

More time spent with patients would mean they would be more easily able to identify potential problems, then they are able to a play a preventative, rather than simply reactive, role. Not only would this lead to fewer patients needing treatment, but it would consequently mean less cost to the NHS.

While employing more nurses will mean more spend in the short term, I believe that the improvement in patient care and long term saving for the Welsh NHS will be worth it.

Posted in news.

Tagged with .


Our role in Europe

The big debate this week in British politics, which featured strongly in PMQs – where I was standing in for the PM – has obviously been about our future role in Europe. An issue on which Jo Grimond was a pioneer and leader.

What’s emerging in this debate is that there are three basic positions. The first is UKIP’s and an increasingly large number of Conservatives’ – they want to leave now. I am clear that would be a calamitous mistake for the country – it would make us poorer, make us less safe and jeopardise millions of jobs and billions of pounds of investment.

The second position is the Conservatives’ official position (at least for now) which amounts to saying to the rest of the EU that they should keep all the EU rules for themselves, but we’ll only abide by the bits we like. It’s a have-your-cake-and-eat it strategy. It might sound seductive, but it’s unlikely to work. Instead it will end up with either largely symbolic concessions from the other 26 member states “inconsequential” in Lord Lawson’s words – or demanding so much that the other EU countries will simply refuse.

The third position is the Liberal Democrats’ position. Of course the EU has to change. It is going to change because it’s in a state of challenge and flux and so needs reform. It must be more competitive, more open, leaner and less bureaucratic. All things Britain should lead from the front on and work constructively with our European partners to achieve.

That is a vision of Europe and Britain’s role in it that our party has long subscribed to. And importantly, it is actually achievable.

And in line with our previous manifesto, and the legislation we passed in 2011, when the EU rules change and new things are asked of the UK within the EU, the British people will have a say in a referendum. We are the first Government ever to give the British people such a guarantee in law.

So there are three positions: we can leave now; we can try and (almost certainly fail) to have our cake and eat it; or we can play our part at the heart of Europe promoting reform and guaranteeing a referendum when the EU rules change affecting Britain.

But as I argued in PMQs to the Tory backbenchers (who by the way seem to have developed an almost unhealthy interest in our Focus leaflets!), people are facing more pressing issues. And it is exactly those issues Liberal Democrats in this Coalition Government are currently taking a lead in tackling.

We won’t always get the attention or coverage we deserve for things we are doing, such as introducing Steve Webb’s single tier pension or the important work Norman Lamb has been talking about this week on Social Care. But we will keep delivering these things that make a real difference to people’s lives.

That is what we are in Government for: anchoring it in the centre ground and building a stronger economy and a fairer society.

Posted in news.

Tagged with .


Post-16 funding proposals need clarity

This week I called for clarity in proposed changes to Post-16 funding in Wales. The proposals are contained in the Welsh Government’s Post-16 Planning and Funding Review: Final report which was published this week.

Any funding programme has to ensure that students are given the best opportunities whilst ensuring that public money is spent efficiently and effectively.

It is clear from my experiences as a member of the Children and Young People Committee that deficiencies currently exist in ensuring that the funding system takes account of both the needs of employers and the subsequent destinations of students.

Given the scale of change and the tight timescale over the timetable – particularly with regard to the work to be undertaken by Careers Wales during 2013 in respect of the Common Area Prospectus and Electronic Application Process – it will be crucial that the organisations involved are clear about their responsibilities.

There is clearly a need for more commonality between the 14-19 networks as well as a need to ensure individual institutions, local authorities and teaching unions are fully engaged in the process given the potential financial impacts on individual institutions and on staff.

It is unclear from today’s statement which employer organisations will be participating in further consultation prior to new guidance being produced in September and I look forward to more details being made available as the project progresses.

Posted in news.

Tagged with .