Skip to content


Defection row rumbles on

Evidence that Plaid Cymru are still smarting over the loss of one of their Assembly Members to the Tories is there for all to see in today’s Western Mail.

The paper reports on a challenge from the newly selected PLaid Cymru PPC for Carmarthen East and Dinefwr, Jonathan Edwards, who wants to know what role was played by David Cameron and Tory Shadow Secretary of State, Cheryl Gillan in the affair.

This is more than an academic question simply because of the reasons given by Mohammed Ashgar in recent days for switching parties. He told a local radio station that he quit Plaid after he was told by party leader Ieuan Wyn Jones that he could not recruit his daughter Natasha as a press officer. The party had earlier decided to ban its elected politicians from employing family members.

As Mr. Edwards points out, this is contrary to the recommendations of the Kelly report into MPs’ expenses which said that in future members should not be able to employ family members. David Cameron has signed his party up to all of the recommendations in this report.

Plaid Cymru may well be regretting selecting Mr. Ashgar for an Assembly seat in the first place, however the Tories must be hoping that now he is with them, he stops trying to justify his defection and gets on with the job. At present neither side is coming out of this affair smelling of roses.

Related posts:

  1. Lembit writes on those defection rumours
  2. Lembit next to experience defection rumours
  3. Another unlikely recruit?

Posted in Uncategorized.

Tagged with , , .


2 Responses

Stay in touch with the conversation, subscribe to the RSS feed for comments on this post.

  1. Saethwyr says

    No reason for Plaid to come out of this damaged Peter. At the end of the day, Mohammed went to the hustings, he was selected democratically, up until the point he was told he couldn’t be nepotistic in his employment practices, he was a member that fully supported Plaid Cymru’s aims.

    If people show their true colours after they are selected and elected… What can anybody do about it?

Continuing the Discussion

  1. Disgusted is back: what you’ve missed « Disgusted of Llandrindod Wells linked to this post on December 16, 2009

    [...] Black tries to tar both Plaid and the Tories. He can only dream about Welsh Lib Dem gaining more than the six seats his party has been stuck on [...]