Freedom Central » Eluned Morgan

A parody by any other name

Peter Black — Sun, 26 Apr 2009 09:49:00 +0000

This morning’s Western Mail speculates that Eluned Morgan’s chances of winning the Labour nomination to replace Rhodri Morgan as the Assembly Member for Cardiff West have been damaged by her involvement in the party’s attack blog, Aneurin Glyndwr.

Eluned wrote a parody of the Tom Jones hit Delilah whose accompanying video depicting Nick Bourne as Dracula and Ieuan Wyn Jones as a clown has been criticised as an example of the infantilisation of Welsh politics.

It also caused severe embarrassment for the First Minister who was forced to backtrack on his previous endorsement of the site, which he appeared to have offered without seeing it first or even fully understanding what the internet is.

Until now, Eluned has been seen as a racing certainty to win the selection for the vacancy when a contest is held later this year. Now, however, there is talk that Eluned’s role in the website debacle has put in doubt the support of the First Minister for her bid to succeed him. The speculation goes a step further in suggesting that Rhodri may have switched his support to Sophie Howe, the unsuccessful Cardiff North Assembly candidate in 2007 who used to work for his wife Julie.

Things really are getting interesting within Welsh Labour.

Y Barcud Oren #7

Gareth Aubrey — Sun, 12 Apr 2009 05:54:00 +0000

It may be late (I blame the author’s man flu, but then I would…) but it’s a bumper Barcud this week as the end-of-term mood added an extra air of lunacy to proceedings.

I’m In Plaid, Get Me Out Of Here

Every writer submitting items for delayed publication risks being overtaken by events. Nevertheless, when I e-mailed off

the last Barcud I had little fear that the sordid question of top-up fees would have developed further by the time it appeared on Lib Dem Voice barely 48 hours later. After all, there was no mention of it in the Assembly business for that week, and it would have taken a pretty pathetic and utterly disgraceful flouting of parliamentary decency for the government to schedule an announcement on such an important topic at the last minute…

Never ones to cock things up by halves, Plaid soon got to work on the really heavy-duty stupidity. Among the documents to appear in the public domain in the aftermath of the announcement was a letter from 17 year-old Plaid member Arianwen Caiach-Taylor, attacking the party for caring more about Ieuan Wyn’ Jones vehicular buttock comfort than the needs of students. John Dixon (yes, the self-same party chairman who’d gotten so much airtime representing the opposition to top-up fees among the grassroots), decided that the only measured response was to expel her from the party altogether, with the classic semantic caveat that he considered her letter to be tantamount to resignation (proving, as much as anything, that he hadn’t read it…). Still, at least she was spared the ignominy of then having to go to Plaid’s spring conference, held at a university (and not just any university, but the one in my ward…)

Meanwhile, Plaid’s fictitious wing were busily reinforcing their position as hypocrites-in-chief, railing against cuts in further education funding at a rally outside the Senedd. As this Welsh Lib Dem video so ably demonstrates, however, that railing would have been a little more meaningful if the members in question hadn’t voted for the budget that made them…

Let no man say, however, that Labour or Plaid are to be found wanting in their brazenness; no sooner had that video appeared than one of the members involved was

asking for the unedited footage so they could put their speech on their website. I don’t suppose the actual response was of the nature of that given to the plaintiff in Arkell vs. Pressdram, but still…

I’m A Stupidly Named Website And So’s My Wife

One of the less publicised features of the One Wales Agreement is the incomptence suicide pact, whereby if one coalition partner is making an arse of itself, the other has to do something equally moronic to spread out the damage. In this case, Labour’s contribution was the launch of Aneurin Glyndwr, a website describing itself as the new digital voice of Labour supporters in Wales.

Appallingly, almost criminally badly written attack blogs are ten a penny, but Aneurin Glyndwr is a different kettle of fish. For starters, it opens with explicit endorsements from Peter Hain MP, Eluned Morgan MEP and Alun Davies AM; indeed, Hain described it as an “Obama moment”. Other commentators were less charitable, and rather more accurate;

• Labour’s John Redwood moment

• A Howard Dean moment

• The internet equivalent of watching your dad dance at a disco

• Like a monkey saw a blog and tried to draw it with a crayon

But rather more unfortunately, Aneurin Glyndwr thinks it’s funny. The site’s opening gambit was a video of that self same Eluned Morgan (who is, we should note, standing down as an MEP, most likely in order to run as Rhodri Morgan’s successor as Assembly Member for Cardiff West in 2011) “singing” a “parody” of Delilah while Plaid’s leadership are depicted in clown hats and the Tories are dressed up as a toff (Cameron) and a vampire (Bourne).

And it is that vampire image in which the real trouble was to be found, even without considering that Labour have become so unimaginative they’re reverting to the same attack they used on Michael Howard 12 years ago (an attack that in that case at least had some semblance of relevance, between the Ann Widdecombe quote and a bit of casual borderline racism.)

Barely six months ago, Labour were fuming after the Tories released a dossier on Rhodri Morgan, marking his 69th birthday by declaring him the Clown Prince of Wales, amongst other personal attacks. Nick Bourne then compounded matters by claiming he hadn’t signed off on the dossier when he had. So there was some surprise when Rhodri claimed that neither he nor Llafur had had prior knowledge of or approved the site. Because he had. Oops?

My Name’s Cheryl And I’m A Conservative

Not to be outdone on the idiocy front, the Tories decided to join the party with a little adventure in human resources. For those who’ve missed her (and frankly, if you’re not Welsh you’re likely to be one of them since almost no-one here has heard of her either), Cheryl Gillan is the Conservative Shadow Secretary of State for Wales and Member of Parliament for those quintessentially Welsh towns, Chesham and Amersham. Since the harsh economic climate doesn’t apply to MPs’ staffing allowances, she’s advertising for a research assistant, shared with David Mundell, MP for Dumfriesshire, Clydesdale and Tweeddale and Shadow Secretary of State for Scotland.

When I broke the story on my blog, I was primarily concerned with the idea that one member of staff could be shared by two countries with different legal and political systems 150 miles apart. By the time it reached the pages of The Western Mail (and no, I’m not at all bitter that they got it from a different blogger…) the issue had metamorphosed into a row about the use of the phrase “knowledge of devolution is desirable, but not essential…” Either way, it’s hardly emblematic of the cuddly, devolution-friendly image the Tories are going for.

Even in the field of reinforcing stereotypes Plaid weren’t going down without a fight though. The aim of their Cardiff conference was to present the party as a modern alternative for everyone in Wales, north and south, east and west, Welsh-speaking and English-speaking. All the self-congratulatory guff about the use of technology was bad enough (yes, Ie Gallen Ni is very shiny, but anyone can make bullshit look pretty) but, lo and behold, one of the keynote speakers managed to get up and launch into an anti-outsider diatribe that even Plaid insiders were describing as “cottage burning”. And while a number of senior party members were leaving the room in disgust, at least one leadership contender gave the performance a warm welcome…

And to finish, the obligatory plug for Welsh Liberal Democrat Spring Conference, which is next weekend at the Barcelo Angel Hotel Cardiff. With three party leaders and something of a bloggers’ get together, there’ll be plenty to report in the next edition of the Barcud.

Y Barcud Oren appears (theoretically) regularly at Liberal Democrat Voice and cross-posted at Freedom Central

Sniping within the coalition

Freedom Central — Sun, 05 Apr 2009 07:37:00 +0000

Welsh Labour’s attack-blog, Aneurin Glyndwr entered new territory yesterday when it directly criticised the performance in government of the Deputy First Minister.

In this instance the author was unhappy at the way that Plaid Cymru are handling the economy portfolio and the contradictory message being sent out by the Government as a consequence:

But the big story that the BBC are continuing to ignore is the chaos that is Plaid’s policy on economic development. We are in the middle of a financial crisis; just about the one thing that politicians of almost every other party can agree on is the need to bring new jobs into Wales.

With unemployment rising, and everyone else tightening their belts, it is simply a disgrace that senior Plaid politicians are allowed to get away with continually campaigning against LNG jobs in Milford Haven, and the new Defence Training Academy in St Athan.

Plaid Deputy President and MEP Jill Evans has a well-paid job in Brussels (for now) so these new jobs might not mean much to her, but they are so important to our communities. Her behaviour is deeply irresponsible.

We at Aneurin Glyndwr certainly have our differences with Ieuan Wyn Jones, but ultimately we believe him to be an honourable man who wants the best for his country. Now the time has come for him to show leadership, as Deputy First Minister of Wales, he should publicly denounce Jill Evans and other senior party figures, before they put more Welsh jobs at risk.

Let us not forget that this website is run by senior Labour Party figures – former Secretary of State for Wales, Peter Hain; Eluned Morgan MEP; and Alun Davies AM. It carries the endorsements of the current Secetary of State, Paul Murphy and the First Minister, Rhodri Morgan. In the circumstances it would be difficult to argue that this personal attack on Ieuan Wyn Jones’ inability to control his own party and deliver on his portfolio is not an official one.

It is now apparent that Plaid Cymru’s insistence on acting as an opposition within government is beginning to try the patience of senior Labour Ministers and is creating strong tensions within the coalition.

Ieuan Wyn Jones’ authority in his own party has already been weakened by these attacks from senior Plaid Cymru members on his actions as a Minister, now the Nationalists’ indiscipline is threatening to unpick the threads tying together the One Wales Administration.

Aneurin Glyndwr – the response

Freedom Central — Sat, 28 Mar 2009 15:44:00 +0000

For some reason certain members of the Welsh blogosphere are obsessing about Labour’s new attack blog Aneurin Glyndwr. There really is no need, it only makes them feel more self-important.

Hen Ferchetan has set up a mirror blog in which she seeks to analyse and respond to every nuance of the Eluned Morgan song as well as identify the site’s authorship. Meanwhile a video has appeared on YouTube offering thanks to the soon-to-be-retiring Labour MEP for her song-writing skills.

Can we move on now please?